Until about four years ago, search marketing has chased a clear target: rank on page one and earn the click. Google made that game predictable. You knew exactly where you stood, whether you ranked first or fifth, and you knew what it took to move up. That certainty has faded, especially in the past two years. People are now asking AI their questions directly instead of searching the internet, and AI has no definitive rankings. Models are inherently a black box, and their reasoning shifts from one update to the next. The brands named in answers win before anyone visits a website. The question is no longer just “where do we rank?” It’s “are we the answer?” And that begs the question: “Answer to what?”
27% of US online shoppers now use AI assistants to help them shop. 45% of shoppers will use AI search at some point this year.¹ In addition, trust hasn’t fully transferred, and especially for high-stakes decisions, people still rely on traditional search over AI. Consumers are cross-checking, which makes consistency across channels more important, not less.
The bottom line is that there is no definitive playbook. The mix of sources AI cites shifts month to month as models update. What’s important to know is that fundamentals still win. Quality content and disciplined SEO remain the ground floor, and technical basics like site speed matter because AI crawlers have to reach and read your pages too. Google owns three of the top four AI tools, so traditional and AI search are converging, not competing.
There’s no way to cheat the system. The brands that win in the age of AI will be the ones already worth recommending, as long as new AI models can find the evidence. Disciplined and relevant content creation, consistent branding, and earned media are not new, but their importance is quickly becoming central to any good marketing strategy.
Interested in talking more about your brand and AI Search? Let’s chat: abbeymecca.com/contact
¹ EMARKETER, A CMO Guide to GEO, https://www.emarketer.com/content/cmo-guide-geo
